clawmail

What this skill does

# Clawmail

Canonical agent coordination contract for joelclaw.

`joelclaw mail` is the **only** supported mail access surface for pi agents.
Do not call `mcp_agent_mail` HTTP endpoints directly from agent prompts or role instructions.

## Interfaces

### Canonical interface
- `joelclaw mail ...` (CLI)

### Pi wrapper tools (allowed, but still CLI-backed)
These wrappers shell to `joelclaw mail` under the hood:

| Tool | CLI equivalent |
|------|----------------|
| `mail_send` | `joelclaw mail send` |
| `mail_inbox` | `joelclaw mail inbox` |
| `mail_read` | `joelclaw mail read` |
| `mail_reserve` | `joelclaw mail reserve` |
| `mail_release` | `joelclaw mail release` |
| `mail_status` | `joelclaw mail status` |

## Required Protocol (default for shared work)

1. **Check inbox before touching files**
   - `joelclaw mail inbox --agent <AgentName> --unread`
2. **Announce active scope**
   - `joelclaw mail send --from <AgentName> --to <AgentName|team> --subject "Starting: <work>" "intent + paths + expected output"`
3. **Reserve file paths before edits**
   - `joelclaw mail reserve --agent <AgentName> --paths "path/a.ts,path/b.ts" [--ttl-seconds 900]`
4. **If work runs long, renew reservation lease**
   - `joelclaw mail renew --agent <AgentName> --paths "path/a.ts" [--extend-seconds 900]`
5. **Send status/handoff updates during work**
   - `joelclaw mail send --subject "Status: ..." ...`
6. **Release reservations after commit/handoff**
   - `joelclaw mail release --agent <AgentName> --paths "..."`
   - or `--all` when done with all reserved paths

## Subject Taxonomy (for searchability + steering)

Use these prefixes consistently:
- `Starting:` — work start / intent announcement
- `Task:` — handoff or assignment
- `Status:` — progress update
- `Blocked:` — dependency/incident requiring intervention
- `Done:` — completion with artifact/commit IDs

Daily steering uses these signals to detect protocol drift.

## Command Quick Reference

```bash
# server + inbox health
joelclaw mail status

# register / refresh identity metadata
joelclaw mail register --agent MaroonReef --program pi --model gpt-5.4 --task "interactive"

# send a coordination message
joelclaw mail send --from MaroonReef --to BlueFox --subject "Task: update prompt docs" "Please edit SYSTEM.md and roles/*.md"

# inbox / read
joelclaw mail inbox --agent MaroonReef --unread
joelclaw mail read --agent MaroonReef --id 12

# reservations
joelclaw mail reserve --agent MaroonReef --paths "SYSTEM.md,roles/interactive.md" --ttl-seconds 900
joelclaw mail renew --agent MaroonReef --paths "SYSTEM.md" --extend-seconds 900
joelclaw mail release --agent MaroonReef --paths "SYSTEM.md,roles/interactive.md"
joelclaw mail release --agent MaroonReef --all

# audit/search
joelclaw mail locks
joelclaw mail search --query "Starting:"
```

## Reliability Checks

### Verify protocol health quickly
```bash
joelclaw mail status
joelclaw mail locks
joelclaw mail search --query "Starting:"
joelclaw mail search --query "Status:"
```

`joelclaw mail locks` should reflect active advisory file reservations from the local git-mailbox `file_reservations/` artifacts when that repo is available. This matters because the raw `/mail/api/locks` endpoint can under-report file reservations while still showing mailbox-internal archive/commit locks.

### If search is degraded (DB/tool errors)
- Treat signal counts as unreliable.
- Continue using protocol anyway (announce/reserve/release).
- Escalate to mail backend health repair and log findings.

### If CLI flags are rejected unexpectedly
- Your compiled `~/.bun/bin/joelclaw` may be stale relative to source.
- Rebuild CLI from `packages/cli/src/cli.ts` and retry.

### If wrapper output says `ok: true` but the nested result contains an error
- Treat the operation as failed. Some CLI paths can return a successful envelope while `result.result` or `result.raw` contains backend errors such as `Too many open files`, `Agent not found`, or stale project metadata.
- Verify reservations/register/inbox calls by reading the nested result, not only the top-level `ok` flag.
- Retry once if the backend says it freed cached repos; if it still fails, continue only for low-risk edits and report the coordination failure in the final summary.
- For repeated `Too many open files. Freed 0 cached repos`, inspect `lsof -p $(pgrep -f 'mcp_agent_mail.*serve-http') | rg '\.(archive|commit)\.lock'`. The durable fix is in `joelhooks/mcp_agent_mail`: close orphaned lock FDs, avoid treating metadata-missing locks as immediately stale, and run `com.joelclaw.agent-mail` with `NumberOfFiles=8192` via `infra/agent-mail-daemon.sh` + `infra/launchd/com.joelclaw.agent-mail.plist`.

## Prompt Authoring Checklist (shore up prompts)

Any prompt/role/system contract that mentions coordination should:

1. Reference **`clawmail`** as canonical protocol skill.
2. State that **mail access is via `joelclaw mail`** (wrappers allowed, direct MCP not allowed).
3. Include at minimum: inbox check, announce, reserve, release.
4. Require path context in coordination messages.
5. Encourage subject prefixes (`Starting:`, `Task:`, `Status:`, `Blocked:`, `Done:`).
6. Avoid filler about mail when no shared edits/coordination are involved.

## Steering Loop Integration

`pi/extensions/session-lifecycle` runs a daily monitor+steer review and emits:
- `agent-mail/steering.reviewed`

Snapshot path:
- `~/.joelclaw/workspace/agent-mail-steering/YYYY-MM-DD.json`

Use steering hints to tighten protocol compliance when drift is detected.

## Related
- `skills/agent-mail/SKILL.md` (compatibility alias)
- `joelclaw mail --help`
- ADR-0172: Agent Mail via MCP Agent Mail