technology-selection

What this skill does

# .NET AI and Machine Learning

## Inputs

| Input | Required | Description |
|-------|----------|-------------|
| Task description | Yes | What the AI/ML feature should accomplish (e.g., "classify support tickets", "summarize documents") |
| Data description | Yes | Type and shape of input data (structured/tabular, unstructured text, images, mixed) |
| Deployment constraints | No | Cloud vs. local, latency SLO, cost budget, offline requirements |
| Existing project context | No | Current .csproj, existing packages, target framework |

## Workflow

### Step 1: Classify the task using the decision tree

Evaluate the developer's task against this decision tree and select the appropriate technology. State which branch applies and why.

| Task type | Technology | Rationale |
|-----------|-----------|-----------|
| Structured/tabular data: classification, regression, clustering, anomaly detection, recommendation | **ML.NET** (`Microsoft.ML`) | Reproducible (given a fixed seed and dataset), no cloud dependency, purpose-built models for these tasks |
| Natural language understanding, generation, summarization, reasoning over unstructured text (single prompt → response, no tool calling) | **LLM via Microsoft.Extensions.AI** (`IChatClient`) | Requires language model capabilities beyond pattern matching; no orchestration needed |
| Agentic workflows: tool/function calling, multi-step reasoning, agent loops, multi-agent collaboration | **Microsoft Agent Framework** (`Microsoft.Agents.AI`) built on top of **Microsoft.Extensions.AI** | Requires orchestration, tool dispatch, iteration control, and guardrails that `IChatClient` alone does not provide |
| Building GitHub Copilot extensions, custom agents, or developer workflow tools | **GitHub Copilot SDK** (`GitHub.Copilot.SDK`) | Integrates with the Copilot agent runtime for IDE and CLI extensibility |
| Running a pre-trained or fine-tuned custom model in production | **ONNX Runtime** (`Microsoft.ML.OnnxRuntime`) | Hardware-accelerated inference, model-format agnostic |
| Local/offline LLM inference with no cloud dependency | **OllamaSharp** with local [AI models supported by Ollama](https://ollama.com/search) | Privacy-sensitive, air-gapped, or cost-constrained scenarios |
| Semantic search, RAG, or embedding storage | **Microsoft.Extensions.VectorData.Abstractions** + a vector database provider (e.g., Azure AI Search, Milvus, MongoDB, pgvector, Pinecone, Qdrant, Redis, SQL) | Provider-agnostic abstractions for vector similarity search; pair with a database-specific connector package (many are moving to community toolkits) |
| Ingesting, chunking, and loading documents into a vector store | **Microsoft.Extensions.AI.DataIngestion** (preview) + **Microsoft.Extensions.VectorData.Abstractions** (MEVD) | Handles document parsing, text chunking, embedding generation, and upserting into a vector database; pairs with Microsoft.Extensions.VectorData.Abstractions |
| Both structured ML predictions AND natural language reasoning | **Hybrid**: ML.NET for predictions + LLM for reasoning layer | Keep loosely coupled; ML.NET handles reproducible scoring, LLM adds explanation |

**Critical rule:** Do NOT use an LLM for tasks that ML.NET handles well (classification on tabular data, regression, clustering). LLMs are slower, more expensive, and non-deterministic for these tasks.

### Step 1b: Select the correct library layer

After identifying the task type, select the right library layer. These libraries form a stack — each builds on the one below it. Using the wrong layer is a major source of non-deterministic agent behavior.

| Layer | Library | NuGet package | Use when |
|-------|---------|---------------|----------|
| **Abstraction** | Microsoft.Extensions.AI (MEAI) | `Microsoft.Extensions.AI` | You need a provider-agnostic interface for chat, embeddings, or tool calling. This is the foundation — always include it. Use `IChatClient` directly **only** for simple prompt-in/response-out scenarios with no tool calling or agentic loops. If the task involves tools, agents, or multi-step reasoning, you must add the Orchestration layer above. |
| **Provider SDK** | OpenAI, Azure.AI.OpenAI, Azure.AI.Inference, OllamaSharp | `OpenAI`, `Azure.AI.OpenAI`, `Azure.AI.Inference`, `OllamaSharp` | You need a concrete LLM provider implementation. These wire into MEAI via `AddChatClient`. Use `OpenAI` for direct OpenAI access, `Azure.AI.OpenAI` for Azure OpenAI, `Azure.AI.Inference` for Azure AI Foundry / GitHub Models, or `OllamaSharp` for local Ollama. Use directly only if you need provider-specific features not exposed through MEAI. |
| **Orchestration** | Microsoft Agent Framework | `Microsoft.Agents.AI` (prerelease) | The task involves tool/function calling, agentic loops, multi-step reasoning, multi-agent coordination, durable context, or graph-based workflows. **This is required whenever the scenario involves agents or tools — do not hand-roll tool dispatch loops with `IChatClient`.** Builds on top of MEAI. **Note:** This package is currently prerelease — use `dotnet add package Microsoft.Agents.AI --prerelease` to install it. |
| **Copilot integration** | GitHub Copilot SDK | `GitHub.Copilot.SDK` | You are building extensions or tools that integrate with the GitHub Copilot runtime — custom agents, IDE extensions, or developer workflow automation that leverages the Copilot agent platform. |

#### Decision rules for library selection

1. **Start with MEAI.** Every AI integration begins with `Microsoft.Extensions.AI` for the `IChatClient` / `IEmbeddingGenerator` abstractions. This ensures provider-swappability and testability.

2. **Add a provider SDK** (`OpenAI`, `Azure.AI.OpenAI`) as the concrete implementation behind MEAI. Do not call the provider SDK directly in business logic — always go through the MEAI abstraction.

3. **Use Agent Framework (`Microsoft.Agents.AI`) for any task that involves tools or agents.** If the task is a single prompt → response with no tool calling, MEAI is sufficient. **You MUST use `Microsoft.Agents.AI`** when any of these apply:
   - Tool/function calling (agent decides which tools to invoke)
   - Multi-step reasoning with state carried across turns
   - Agentic loops that iterate until a goal is met
   - Multi-agent collaboration with handoff protocols
   - Graph-based or durable workflows

   Do **not** implement these patterns by hand with `IChatClient` — the Agent Framework provides iteration limits, observability, and tool dispatch that are error-prone to reimplement.

4. **Add Copilot SDK only when building Copilot extensions.** Use `GitHub.Copilot.SDK` when the goal is to build a custom agent or tool that runs inside the GitHub Copilot platform (CLI, IDE, or Copilot Chat). This is not a general-purpose LLM orchestration library — it is specifically for Copilot extensibility.

5. **Never skip layers.** Do not use Agent Framework without MEAI underneath. Do not call `HttpClient` to OpenAI alongside MEAI in the same workflow. Each layer depends on the one below it.

### Step 2: Select packages and set up the project

Install only the packages needed for the selected technology branch. Do not mix competing abstractions.

#### Classic ML packages

```xml
<PackageReference Include="Microsoft.ML" Version="4.*" />
<PackageReference Include="Microsoft.ML.AutoML" Version="0.*" />
<!-- Only if custom numerical work is needed: -->
PackageReference Include="System.Numerics.Tensors" Version="10.*"
<PackageReference Include="MathNet.Numerics" Version="5.*" />
<!-- Only for data exploration: -->
<PackageReference Include="Microsoft.Data.Analysis" Version="0.*" />
```

> **Do NOT use** Accord.NET — it is archived and unmaintained.

#### Modern AI packages

```xml
<!-- Always start with the abstraction layer -->
<PackageReference Include="Microsoft.Extensions.AI" Version="9.*" />

<!-- Orchestration (agents, workflows, tools, memory) — prerelease; use dotnet add package Microsoft.Agents.AI --prerelease -->
<Packag