afrexai-competitive-intel

What this skill does

# Competitive Intelligence Engine

A complete system for understanding, tracking, and outmaneuvering competitors. Covers market mapping, product analysis, pricing intelligence, sales battlecards, win/loss analysis, and ongoing monitoring.

## When to Use

- Entering a new market or launching a product
- Losing deals to competitors and need to understand why
- Quarterly strategy reviews
- Pricing decisions (new product or adjustment)
- Sales team needs competitive talking points
- M&A due diligence on a target or acquirer
- Investor pitch prep (show you understand the landscape)
- Content strategy informed by competitor gaps

---

## Phase 1: Market Mapping

### 1.1 Competitor Identification

Classify every competitor into one of four tiers:

| Tier | Definition | Example | Monitoring Frequency |
|------|-----------|---------|---------------------|
| **Direct** | Same product, same buyer | Your closest rivals | Weekly |
| **Adjacent** | Different product, overlapping buyer | Platform expanding into your space | Bi-weekly |
| **Indirect** | Different solution to same problem | Spreadsheets replacing your SaaS | Monthly |
| **Emerging** | Early-stage, same vision | YC startups in your category | Monthly |

### Discovery Methods

Search these sources systematically:

1. **Google**: "[your category] software/tool/service" — note top 10 organic + ads
2. **G2/Capterra/TrustRadius**: Your category page — note top 10 by reviews
3. **Product Hunt**: Search your keywords — sort by votes
4. **Crunchbase**: Search your category — filter funded companies
5. **LinkedIn**: "[competitor name]" company pages — note employee count trends
6. **Reddit/HN**: "alternative to [leader]" or "[category] recommendations"
7. **Customer interviews**: "Who else did you evaluate?"
8. **Lost deal notes**: Who did you lose to and why?

### Market Map YAML

```yaml
market_map:
  category: "[Your Category]"
  date: "YYYY-MM-DD"
  total_addressable_market: "$XB"
  
  competitors:
    - name: "Competitor A"
      tier: "direct"
      website: "https://..."
      founded: 2019
      funding: "$50M Series B"
      estimated_revenue: "$10-20M ARR"
      employee_count: 150
      employee_trend: "growing"  # growing | stable | shrinking
      hq: "San Francisco, CA"
      key_customers: ["Customer 1", "Customer 2"]
      primary_market: "mid-market"  # smb | mid-market | enterprise
      positioning: "All-in-one platform for X"
      strengths: ["Feature A", "Strong brand"]
      weaknesses: ["Expensive", "Slow support"]
      threat_level: "high"  # low | medium | high | critical
      notes: ""
```

---

## Phase 2: Product Teardown

### 2.1 Feature Matrix

For each direct competitor, build a feature comparison:

```yaml
feature_matrix:
  last_updated: "YYYY-MM-DD"
  
  categories:
    - name: "Core Features"
      features:
        - name: "Feature X"
          us: "full"       # none | partial | full | superior
          competitor_a: "full"
          competitor_b: "partial"
          weight: 5        # 1-5 importance to buyer
          notes: "We have deeper customization"
          
        - name: "Feature Y"
          us: "none"
          competitor_a: "full"
          competitor_b: "full"
          weight: 3
          notes: "On our roadmap for Q3"
    
    - name: "Integrations"
      features:
        - name: "Salesforce"
          us: "full"
          competitor_a: "partial"
          weight: 4
```

### 2.2 Product Teardown Template

For each major competitor, conduct a structured teardown:

```markdown
## [Competitor Name] Product Teardown
**Date:** YYYY-MM-DD
**Analyst:** [name]

### First Impressions (0-5 min)
- Homepage messaging: What problem do they lead with?
- Sign-up friction: How many steps? What info required?
- Time to value: How fast can you DO something?
- Design quality: Modern, dated, cluttered, clean?

### Onboarding (5-30 min)
- Guided tour? Checklist? Video? Nothing?
- Sample data provided? Sandbox mode?
- How quickly did you feel competent?
- What confused you?

### Core Workflow
- Complete their primary use case end-to-end
- Note: steps required, clicks per task, speed, error handling
- Screenshot key screens

### Differentiators
- What can they do that we can't? (be honest)
- What's their "magic moment"?
- What do their happiest customers praise? (check G2 reviews)

### Weaknesses
- Where did you get stuck?
- What felt missing or half-baked?
- What do their angriest customers complain about? (check G2 1-2 star reviews)

### Pricing vs Value
- What plan would a typical customer need?
- Price per user/month at that tier?
- Any hidden costs (implementation, support, integrations)?
- Free trial? Freemium? Money-back guarantee?

### Technical Assessment
- Stack: (check Wappalyzer, BuiltWith, job postings)
- API: Public? REST/GraphQL? Rate limits? Docs quality?
- Mobile: Native app? Responsive web? PWA?
- Performance: Page load speed, UI responsiveness
- Uptime: Status page? Historical incidents?
```

### 2.3 UX Scoring Rubric

Score each competitor's product (0-10 per dimension):

| Dimension | What to Evaluate | Weight |
|-----------|-----------------|--------|
| **Ease of Setup** | Time to first value, onboarding friction | 15% |
| **Core UX** | Primary workflow efficiency, intuitiveness | 25% |
| **Feature Depth** | Covers edge cases, power user needs | 20% |
| **Reliability** | Uptime, bugs encountered, error handling | 15% |
| **Integrations** | Ecosystem breadth, API quality | 10% |
| **Support** | Response time, quality, self-serve resources | 10% |
| **Mobile** | Native quality, feature parity | 5% |

**Total = weighted sum. Compare across competitors.**

---

## Phase 3: Pricing Intelligence

### 3.1 Pricing Comparison Table

```yaml
pricing_intel:
  date: "YYYY-MM-DD"
  
  competitors:
    - name: "Us"
      model: "per-seat"  # per-seat | usage | flat | hybrid | freemium
      entry_price: "$29/user/mo"
      mid_price: "$79/user/mo"
      enterprise_price: "Custom"
      free_tier: true
      free_limits: "5 users, 1000 records"
      annual_discount: "20%"
      contract_required: false
      implementation_fee: "$0"
      hidden_costs: []
      
    - name: "Competitor A"
      model: "per-seat"
      entry_price: "$49/user/mo"
      mid_price: "$99/user/mo"
      enterprise_price: "Custom ($150+/user)"
      free_tier: false
      annual_discount: "15%"
      contract_required: true  # annual minimum
      implementation_fee: "$5,000"
      hidden_costs: ["API access on enterprise only", "SSO $50/user extra"]
```

### 3.2 Price Positioning Analysis

Answer these questions:

1. **Where do we sit?** Map all competitors on a 2x2: Price (low→high) vs Feature depth (basic→advanced)
2. **Who's cheapest?** At 10 users? 50 users? 200 users? (pricing often crosses over at scale)
3. **Total Cost of Ownership**: Include implementation, training, migration, hidden fees
4. **Value ratio**: Features-per-dollar compared to each competitor
5. **Pricing trend**: Are competitors raising prices? (check Wayback Machine on /pricing)
6. **Discount behavior**: Do they discount aggressively in deals? (ask sales team, check G2 reviews mentioning price)

### 3.3 Pricing Strategy Recommendations

Based on analysis, recommend one of:

| Strategy | When to Use | Risk |
|----------|------------|------|
| **Premium** | Clearly superior product + brand | Losing price-sensitive deals |
| **Parity** | Similar product, compete on other axes | Race to bottom |
| **Penetration** | New entrant, need market share fast | Perception of low quality |
| **Value** | Better product at lower price | Margin pressure if costs rise |
| **Niche** | Specialized for segment competitors ignore | Small TAM |

---

## Phase 4: Sales Battlecards

### 4.1 Battlecard Template

Create one per direct competitor:

```markdown
# 🏆 Battlecard: Us vs [Competitor]
**Last Updated:** YYYY-MM-DD | **Confidence:** High/Medium/Low

## Quick Stats
| Metric | Us | Them |
|--------|-----|------|
| Founded | | |
| Fu